Skip to Navigation

Amitava Chattopadhyay


Amitava Chattopadhyay
Emerging Market Multinationals - Amitava Chattopadhyay


Responsible journalism needed!

In an opinion piece in The Wall Street Journal today (September 26, 2013), entitled “India’s Attack on Innovation,” Mr. Rod Hunter, a Senior Vice President at the Pharmaceutical Manufacturers of America, made claims that are incredibly specious and self-serving arguments to bolster his thesis that the Indian government was attacking innovation.

First of all, the title is a gross generalization of the topic of his article which is about pharmaceutical patents. I agree that one should debate the Indian Government’s decisions regarding accepting pharmaceutical patents. However, the debate needs to be based on reasonable arguments and examined from all sides.

The Wall Street Journal should be embarrassed to publish an opinion peace that is vacuous in its arguments and pander to the public with gross over generalizations, even if this would serve Mr. Hunter’s goals.

Let’s examine Mr. Hunter’s arguments for why India should not be allowed to reject pharmaceutical patents granted elsewhere in the world, to get needed medicines at an affordable price to its citizens. The first argument made by Mr. Hunter has merit. He argues that the motives of the government are not altruistic but play to the demands of India’s domestic pharmaceutical players. However, his remaining arguments are about as ridiculous as any that I have heard. Mr. Hunter’s claim that India is not poor is ridiculous. India’s per capita income is less than US$3000/annum on even a PPP basis! That is less than 10% that of the US or for that matter the G7 average per capita income! Arguing that India has 150 million middle class consumers and should thus not worry about the cost of medication is equally ridiculous. It conveniently ignores the fact that India has a population of 1.2 billion and thus government policies cannot be directed at just 12.5% of the population. Government policy needs to encompass the majority. Finally, claiming that India is rich because Mumbai has a GDP greater than Hungary is an embarrassingly foolish argument! The per capita income in Mumbai remains less than In Hungary and the wealthy city of Mumbai comprises less than 2% of India’s population.

The Wall Street Journal should take a little care to ensure that they don’t publish opinion pieces that are inflammatory but don’t stand up to any intelligent scrutiny at all. This of course assumes that it aspires to journalistic standards higher than the National Enquirer!

  Sep 26, 2013 | Musings




THEMES

 
 
 
 


SHARE

 


Recent Tweets



Thu, 15 Apr @ 04:28 pm

How predictable. The entire GoI has either been lobotomized, we're terminally stupid to begin with, or are irrespon… https://t.co/zPK6XgcMHv

via Hootsuite Inc.
Tue, 13 Apr @ 02:37 pm

Mad dog muzzled and put on leash. 48 hours too short to diagnose rabies! "Bengal Assembly elections | EC notice to… https://t.co/yMb7gK0hY7

via Hootsuite Inc.
Tue, 13 Apr @ 01:40 pm

How could 26 year veteran make such mistake? Importantly, she wasn't under threat & "crime" if any, was minor. Thou… https://t.co/kfSPfdbyFb

via Hootsuite Inc.
Sun, 11 Apr @ 05:55 pm

Mad dogs should be??? "Bengal BJP president warns of more Sitalkuchi-like shootings, draws condemnation" https://t.co/E6c883hJzs

via Hootsuite Inc.
Wed, 07 Apr @ 04:06 pm

What a backward mindset. As backward as his cricket was good! "Imran Khan criticised for rape 'victim blaming'"… https://t.co/9QjhMlCqjE

via Hootsuite Inc.
Sat, 27 Mar @ 05:55 am

Does he even realize that he sounds like a moron, given his inherently contradictory statement? Is stupidity a qual… https://t.co/awK8VyRuBz

via Hootsuite Inc.

  Close About Papers Cases Books Teaching Musings Media Gallery Ask Amitava